Default Bail Under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C./ 187(3) BNSS: A Valuable Right of the Accused
By Advocate Avichal Pandey, Allahabad High Court
In criminal law, personal liberty occupies a central place under the Constitution of India. At the same time, the State is empowered to investigate crimes and prosecute offenders in accordance with law. To maintain a balance between individual liberty and effective investigation, the law prescribes strict timelines for filing a charge-sheet. If the investigating agency fails to complete the investigation within the prescribed period, the accused acquires a statutory right known as “Default Bail” or “Statutory Bail.”
Default bail is one of the most significant safeguards available to an accused person under criminal jurisprudence. It ensures that a person is not kept behind bars indefinitely due to delay on the part of the investigating agency.
Meaning of Default Bail
Default bail is provided under Section 167(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (now substantially reflected under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023). It comes into operation when the police fail to file a charge-sheet within the prescribed statutory period.
The law prescribes two timelines:
●90 days – where the offence is punishable with death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment not less than 10 years.
●60 days – in all other offences.
If the charge-sheet is not filed within the applicable period, the accused becomes entitled to be released on bail, provided he applies for the same and is ready to furnish bail bonds.
Object Behind Default Bail
The provision exists to prevent arbitrary and prolonged detention during investigation. Investigation agencies cannot keep an accused in custody endlessly without completing investigation.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that default bail is not merely a procedural formality but an “indefeasible right” flowing from Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which guarantees personal liberty.
When Does the Right to Default Bail Arise?
The right accrues immediately after expiry of the statutory period of detention.
For example:-
If the accused is remanded for an offence carrying punishment above 10 years, and no charge-sheet is filed within 90 days, then on the 91st day the accused acquires the right to seek default bail.
Similarly, in offences covered by the 60-day category, the right arises on the 61st day.
However, mere expiry of time does not automatically release the accused from custody.
Essential Conditions for Grant of Default Bail
1. Filing of an Application by the Accused
The accused must formally apply before the court seeking default bail. Oral submissions alone are generally insufficient.
The Supreme Court in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra clarified that the accused must invoke the right by moving an application and expressing readiness to furnish bail.
Thus, the court cannot grant default bail suo motu merely because the statutory period has expired.
2. Investigation Must Still Be Pending
Default bail is available only till the filing of the charge-sheet. Once the charge-sheet is filed, Section 167 ceases to apply and custody thereafter is governed by other provisions of criminal procedure.
The landmark judgment in Sanjay Dutt v. State held that the right to default bail survives only until the charge-sheet is filed.
Therefore:
If the accused applies before filing of the charge-sheet, the right survives.
If the charge-sheet is filed before the accused avails the remedy, the right gets extinguished.
This principle is extremely important in practice because even a delay of a few hours can impact the entitlement of the accused.
Meaning of “Availed Of” the Right
An important legal question arose before the Supreme Court - When can it be said that the accused has “availed of” the right to default bail?
The answer was provided in Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra.
The Court held that the accused is deemed to have availed the right the moment:-
●An application for default bail is filed
●The accused expresses willingness to furnish bail.
Actual release from jail is not necessary for preservation of the right.
This interpretation protects the accused from delays caused by court procedures or prosecution tactics.
What Happens if Charge-Sheet and Bail Application are Filed on the Same Day?
This is one of the most litigated issues concerning default bail.
Courts have generally held that if the charge-sheet is filed before the court considers the bail application, then the right may not survive because the stage under Section 167(2) comes to an end.
The Delhi High Court in Sanjay Bhatia v. State observed that after filing of the charge-sheet, the accused can seek only regular bail on merits.
Therefore, timing becomes crucial in matters relating to default bail.
Can Default Bail Be Cancelled After Filing of Charge-Sheet?
Filing of the charge-sheet after release on default bail does not automatically cancel the bail.
The Supreme Court in Mohammed Iqbal Madar v. State of Maharashtra held that once default bail is granted, cancellation can only occur on settled principles applicable to cancellation of bail,
such as:-
●Misuse of liberty,
●Tampering with evidence,
●Influencing witnesses,
●Absconding, etc.
Thus, subsequent filing of the charge-sheet alone is not enough to cancel bail.
Constitutional Perspective
Default bail is deeply connected with the constitutional guarantee of personal liberty under Article 21.
The provision acts as a check upon arbitrary detention and compels investigating agencies to complete investigation within reasonable time. It reflects the principle that liberty cannot be sacrificed merely because the State has failed to complete investigation diligently.
Indian courts have consistently emphasized that procedural safeguards protecting liberty must receive liberal interpretation.
Practical Importance in Criminal Litigation
For criminal lawyers and litigants, default bail is an extremely technical but powerful remedy. In many cases:-
●Calculation of remand period,
●Exact timing of filing of charge-sheet,
●Timing of filing of bail application,
●Readiness to furnish bonds
Even minor procedural lapses can determine whether an accused remains in custody or secures release.
Therefore, prompt legal advice and vigilant monitoring of remand dates are essential in criminal cases.
Conclusion
Default bail is not a concession granted by the court; it is a statutory and constitutional right arising from the failure of the investigating agency to complete investigation within prescribed time.
The law seeks to strike a balance between societal interest and personal liberty. While investigation of crime is important, indefinite incarceration without timely completion of investigation is contrary to the rule of law.
Courts across India, including the Allahabad High Court, have repeatedly upheld the sanctity of this right.
Understanding the nuances of default bail is therefore indispensable for every accused person, criminal practitioner, and law student dealing with criminal litigation.
Author:
Advocate Avichal Pandey
Practicing at Allahabad High Court
Post a Comment